More Is Better! Isn’t It?

“Come on down, folks! We’ve got the biggest, the best, the most mind-boggling array of stuff you didn’t even know you needed!” The classic sales pitch, gracing our TV and radio airwaves for more years than we care to count. Because, you know, more is always better, right? At least, that’s the gospel according to popular opinion. So, is there such a thing as too much choice?

Ever found yourself in the grocery store, frozen in front of a wall of pasta sauces, as if you’re choosing the Holy Grail of marinara? The paralysis of too many options is a real struggle that we face everyday.

The Fantasy of Unlimited Choices

We’ve been conditioned to believe that more is always better. More money, more friends, more choices. We use the same logic when it comes to our kids. We offer them virtually unlimited choices. Choices that tend to be constricted only by our financial ability. Any deviation from this makes us feel like bad parents. What if I told you that it’s all a myth!

You see, the myth of “more is better” isn’t just a cultural idiom; it’s a marketing strategy. It’s one of the most effective ones at inducing FOMO (fear of missing out). It’s the reason that it has such an enduring legacy among advertisers. Big-box retailers have been selling us this idea for years. “Why settle for one type of cereal when you can choose from fifty?” they say. But what they don’t tell you is that this abundance of choice is not only unnecessary but also counterproductive.

A fascinating study titled “Can there ever be too many options? A meta-analytic review of choice overload” found that having too many choices can actually lead to negative outcomes. The study challenges the conventional wisdom that too many choices can leave you worse off. It turns out, it can.

So, when we transfer this “more is better” mentality to our parenting, like in the realm of food choices, we’re setting ourselves—and our kids—up for failure. We’re not just making mealtime more complicated; we’re teaching our children that life is an endless buffet, where the only limit is their appetite. So what’s the solution?

Curated Choices—The Art of Simplified Decision-Making

How do we teach our children to make wise choices without overwhelming them? The answer is simpler than you might think: curated choices.

The concept of curated choices is not new. In fact, it’s how some of the most successful businesses operate. Take Trader Joe’s and Costco, for example. These retailers have limited assortments of products, yet they lead the charts in customer satisfaction and sales per square foot. Why? Because they’ve done the hard work of curating choices for us. They’ve sifted through the noise and presented us with the best options, making our lives easier and our shopping experiences more enjoyable.

So why not apply this principle to parenting? Instead of offering an endless array of food options, why not curate a selection of healthy, balanced meals for your child to choose from? For instance, instead of asking, “What do you want for breakfast?” you could say, “Would you like oatmeal with fruit or scrambled eggs with spinach?”

By doing this, you’re achieving several things:

1. Simplifying the Decision-Making Process: You’re making it easier for your child to make a choice, thereby reducing decision fatigue.
2. Empowering Through Choice: You’re still giving your child the power to choose, which is essential for building confidence and independence.
3. Promoting Healthy Choices: By curating the options, you’re ensuring that whatever choice your child makes, it’s a healthy one.
4. Teaching the Value of Limitations: You’re subtly teaching your child that limitations aren’t necessarily bad; they can actually be freeing.

Takeaways

As a parent, you possess a lot of experience and wisdom that your children have yet to acquire. The biggest obstacle when making a decision is lack of information. You have made a lot of decisions throughout your life. So, while it’s crucial to give your children the room to make mistakes and learn from them, guiding them toward better choices is equally important. Asking them to make choices, absent of context or an understanding of the consequences, you’re setting them up for failure and frustration.

By curating options for your children, you achieve a balance: you eliminate poor choices based on your own insights, while still empowering them to make decisions that affect them.

Well, that’s my opinion what do you think?

Before you go, sign up for our weekly dose of parenting laughs, commiseration, and hacks.